moonchildhippy
Group: Members
Posts: 1807
Joined: Dec. 2004 |
|
Posted: Sep. 12 2006, 07:51 |
|
Quote (TOBY @ Sep. 12 2006, 09:02) | I don't by any means think its the main reason people don't contribute much these days but there have unquestionably been instances of people being bullied for daring to express an opinion, no matter how controversial (Ian Too springs to mind, some people here wanted to burn him at the stake) But I wouldn't say it happens a lot and it certainly hasn't happened recently.
As you say Alan there's just not much happening in Mike's career just now plus there's a lot of fan apathy towards him these days. It'll probably change if this book ever comes out and especially if he ever tours again. |
Quote | TubularBelle Posted on Sep. 12 2006, 10:45yeh but Ian Too wasn't just bagging one or two of Mikes albums, he was saying really horrible things about Mike as a person, I have no respect for him anymore etc etc. Everyone has a right to an opinion, but this is a Mike Oldfield forum and if you can't stand Mike anymore, surely you should just quietly move on to something else. I still come in here every day as always and have a look around but if nothing is being posted then I have nothing to contribute. |
I agree I feel that a minority of the posts on here have gone too far down the slippery slope, attacking Mike (and sometimes other TubularBoard members) personally. Mike's personal life is not something I wish to pry into warts and all,after all we're all human and we all make mistakes from time to time. Yes I do feel much of Mike's emotions is reflected in his music, after all I feel it would be impossible to compose or play music if devoid of emotions. Saying that I'm looking forward to reading Mike's autobiography,but I do feel there's a HUGE difference between attacking Mike based on vicious rumours, and say reading a biography or the transcript of an interview.
Quote | Alan D Posted on Sep. 12 2006, 08:47 Quote (TOBY @ Sep. 11 2006, 22:05) I think a fair few people have been chased away from these forums for 'daring' to have an opinion and 'daring' to express it. The old argument of 'don't contribute here if don't have anything good to say' has now come to fruition.
I must say that I haven't really encountered this. There are hundreds of unfavourable responses to much of Mike's music to be found in this forum (I've contributed some of them myself), but although (of course) many of those have been hotly debated both ways, I can't imagine that anyone could be scared off for daring to have an opinion?
If someone says 'Tr3s Lunas is rubbish', then it's very likely to produce a response from me in disagreement; equally, if someone says that Amarok is one of the greatest pieces of music ever written, then I'm likely to suggest they're being overzealous. I think L&S is disturbingly vacuous. Either way, I feel free to state my opinion without being chased away.
The other reason is more likely: things are just not very exciting at the moment. |
I've never had a problem with being shouted down or feeling chased away just for expressing an opinion, I do much prefer the original Tubular Bells to Tubular Bells 2003,but equally I can accept that some fans will prefer TB2003 to the original. . My guess that the board is a bit quiet at the mo is, I guess so many of us have busy lives and other commitments, it's not always possible to find the time to look/post here regularly. There is often a flurry of activity after say an album or DVD release,or Mike gives an interview. With the NOTP Concerts and the autobiography in the pipeline I'm sure activity will pick up.
-------------- I'm going slightly mad, It finally happened, I'm slightly mad , just very slightly mad
If you feel a little glum to Hergest Ridge you should come.
I'm challenging taboos surrounding mental health
"Part time hippy"
I'M SUPPORTING OUR SOLDIERS
BRING OUR TROOPS HOME NOW!!
|