GusFogle
Group: Members
Posts: 199
Joined: July 2011 |
|
Posted: June 06 2012, 09:40 |
|
Honestly, no offense was intended on my part. The point about the general public is one I hadn't considered. It is just a different type of performance, a different format, more akin to a "theatrical event" than a classical concert. There's no reason to say one's better than the other, but I suppose the purist in me reacted to the sequencing, which by the way, even if it is "applied" live, takes the physical demand out of actually playing things like that bass part which repeats for so long and is quite challenging on the original piece.
But you are definitely correct that the general public would expect a "Tubular Bells" concert to sound just like the album, and the 2 guys do a great job of that, regardless of their means.
And no, what I said would not imply sounding just like the album, it would imply it sounding different to the album, which we already established the general public wouldn't want to hear- even though almost every performance Mike has done of TB was different than the album version as far as instrumentation and arrangement.
As far as sour grapes- that's just foolishness. I have no desire to put on that kind of show, nor could I hop from one instrument to the next if I wanted to. I wish the 2 guys the best, it seems they've been quite successful performing TB. And in the end, anyone that brings Mike's music to the public is doing a service to us all.
|